Pizza Madness Maui

Reviews

• Nina J.

  star star star star star 29 June 2026

  Great pizza!!! It's a fun place to go watch a game, hang out with friends or get it to go.
  Pizza is always loaded with fresh ingredients and never feels skimpy.
  We always get 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 Hawaiian and are never disappointed!
  Beer is always cold!
  Friendly waitstaff!!

• Denise D.

  star star star star star_border 28 June 2026

  Tl;Dr I'd come back if I were in the mood for some pizza. Creepy outside of restaurant, but relaxed and great vibes inside of restaurant
  
  A T M O S P H E R E
  We called ahead of time to place our order. The male server receiving the order, confirmed the order by verbal readback, which was much appreciated.
  
  We came on a Monday night in Dec at 7pm. When we arrived, it was super creepy. Outside has a dirt parking lot. Looks like an abandoned area, with very poor lighting. When we went into the restaurant though, it was popping. So many people! All the tables were full. 15 people waiting to be seated. 7 people in the to go line.
  
  Restaurant had multiple TV's playing football, basketball, etc. Alcoholic bar. Large benches for tables (like the ones at the park, but nicer in aesthetic).
  
  Family friendly. Great for couples and friends to kick it.
  
  F O O D
  large 16in special $30: thick crust pizza. A ton of toppings. Tasty and hot. So good.
  
  large 16in meat lover + extra pineapple $32: thick crust pizza. A ton of toppings. Tasty and hot. So good.
  
  Family salad with house dressing $15: they forgot to give us the house dressing which we didn't realize until we got back lol but the salad was good. Just your basic salad with an ample amount of mozzarella cheese.
  
  2 fried chicken, spicy, ranch dressing: beautifully fried. Soooo good. The chicken itself wasn't really spicy but the hot sauce it came with was tasty. Not that spicy imo.  
  
  S E R V I C E
  Considering how busy they were, quite quick! The servers were all hustling and bustling. They were able to multi task quite well and seemed very amicable.
  
  P R I C E
  95. A little expensive but I can see why. Not bad considering the amount of food we got

• Jessica C.

  star star star star star_border 23 June 2026

  Solid good pizza. Plus beer. Has a divey local feel and doesn't seem to be in the best part of town, but if you're in the area, why not grab a laid back bite to eat. Toppings tasted fresh, the crust was good, and prices were reasonable. Service was good too.
  
  I would come back next time I'm in town if I'm craving better than dominos but similar style pizza.

• Kimi Anne A.

  star star star star star_border 6 June 2026

  There's something about freshly made pizza, garlicky garlic knots and a cold beer. The fam bam and I stopped here after a day in Wailea.
  
  The mister went ahead and ordered a medium bacon, mushroom and pepperoni pizza, cheese sticks and we had a large stein of beer.
  
  The servers are cheery and full of smiles. They not only catered to us, but also to the little. She was gifted with a coloring page and crayons. You can't go wrong with making a little happy. Like they say.... happy kids = happy adults
  
  The pizza arrived quickly. Perfectly crisp crust, gooey cheese and fresh sauce. The bacon was just right with a bit of crisp and some chew, the mushroom wasn't canned (canned is a sin) and that gooey cheese was so so so delish!
  
  The little was happy with her cheese sticks. Like the pizza... it was nice and gooey. Hearing her giggle as she pulled and the sting got longer and longer was definitely music to the ears.
  
  Prices are reasonable. Clean restaurant. Full tummy. Stop by for some delicious pizza and catch a game on one of their many televisions in the restaurant.

• Tim E.

  star star star star star_border 2 June 2026

  Good, fast, and inexpensive, Pizza madness is a safe bet and a crowd please for kids and adults alike. We ordered a custom pizza, and noticed the strong crust. Noticeable sauce, and chewy (in a good way) cheese, as well as fresh ingredients, that lead to a pizza disappearing act! Also, Pizza Madness Maui was open on Christmas Eve.